Skip to content

Big win – National Landscape, Green Belt, grey belt appeal dismissed!

19th November 2026

CPRE Hertfordshire is delighted to celebrate a big campaign win, with the appeal dismissal of a speculative major development application at Bulbourne Wood, Northchurch, Berkhamsted in Dacorum Borough. The site is in the Green Belt and in the Chilterns National Landscape. The planning balance and appeal dismissal is unequivocal and has implications far beyond Hertfordshire.

Dacorum planning application 24/02705/MOA was a speculative proposal for a 67 bed specialist dementia care home and associated works on a woodland site. The site is in both the Green Belt and in the Chilterns National Landscape. It is also in the impact zone for the internationally designated Chilterns Beechwoods Special Area of Conservation (SAC).

The Council refused permission in 2025 and the applicant lodged an appeal. The Planning Inspectorate conducted appeal hearings earlier this year, in which we participated as an Interested Party arguing for dismissal of the appeal.

Now, the Planning Inspector has issued the decision notice: permission is refused and the appeal is dismissed. Reasons for dismissal include:

  • harm to the Green Belt from inappropriate development and no very special circumstances
  • harm to the National Landscape and lack of exceptional circumstances
  • harm to protected woodlands
  • harm to the SAC, and
  • the site being an unsustainable location.

This is a big win for the Green Belt and for the Chilterns National Landscape.

It is also a notable case in which the applicant’s ‘grey belt’ argument was found to have merit but did not tilt the planning balance in favour of permission.

The full appeal decision notice is available for download here. Several extracts from the Planning Inspector’s decision are listed below.

Download the appeal decision

We’re delighted to have played a role in this planning case. Please join us and help us continue to protect the Hertfordshire countryside for everyone, both for today and for the future. It’s easy and quick to join online.

– – –

The Planning Inspector found the following. (All policy references are to the National Planning Policy Framework, August 2026).

Grey Belt. At paragraph 22:

“I am satisfied that development on this site would not fundamentally undermine the purposes (taken together) of the remaining Green Belt across the plan area. This is the test set out in Policy GB7:1 g) i). As such, the site is grey belt.”

Sustainable Location. At paragraphs 42- 44:

“I conclude that there would not be a genuine choice of convenient or alternative transport modes, and that there would be dependence on private vehicles…”  Therefore “This would not be a sustainable location.”

Golden Rules. At paragraph 53:

“Although I disagree with the Council in this regard, I have concluded that the Golden Rules would not be met.”

Woodland.  At paragraph 100:

“I conclude that there would be an adverse effect on the protected woodland over and above what is set out. The development would be contrary to Policy N2 of the Framework which states that development should contribute positively to the natural environment, and conserve and enhance existing natural features where possible… “

Planning Balance.  At paragraphs 194-199:

“The site has multiple statutory designations, any one of which could ordinarily preclude development.”

“Policy GB6:2 of the Framework states that substantial weight should be given to harm to the Green Belt arising from inappropriate development.” And “I have also found harm in relation to protected woodlands, the protected landscape, the SAC and location.”

“With regard to the protected landscapes, Policy N4 of the Framework states that major development within protected landscapes should be refused other than in exceptional circumstances. I have found that exceptional circumstances do not exist. With regard to the SAC, I have concluded that the benefits would not outweigh the harm to the SAC. I am also unable to conclude that there would not be significant harm to biodiversity and in such cases Policy N2 of the Framework states that development should be refused.”

“Policy DP3:1 of the Framework requires development to respond to its context. Policy DP3:2 of the Framework sets out that development should also reflect liveability and be easy to look after, strengthen habitats and in terms of movement, to provide good connections to the wider settlement, amongst other requirements. I have set out in my reasoning how the development would fail to meet these requirements.”

“The provision of additional bedspaces, including affordable bedspaces, together with a moderate economic boost, and a small area of public open space carry only moderate weight in favour of the appeal. Moreover, the evidence indicates that this is not a suitable site for a dementia care home and other sites are available. As such, the evidence fails to provide clear justification.”

“Policy S5 of the Framework is concerned with the principle of development outside settlements. However, it does not apply to development proposals in the Green Belt. The other considerations and benefits arising from the development are not sufficient to outweigh the harm to the Green Belt, and all the other identified harm, and as such very special circumstances do not exist.”

Download the appeal decision

an attractive woodland in wintertime
Bulbourne Wood, Northchurch CPRE Hertfordshire